Introduction
Effective management of a school depends on the efforts of a
number of agencies that are closely interlinked. The regional
or provincial office, the district office, the local community
and the school staff, to name the obvious, all play a part in
the daily operation of the school. The head is the pivotal link
in this network and, ultimately, plays the most crucial role
in ensuring school effectiveness. This role is, however, complex
and demanding. It involves management of financial, human and
material resources in a dynamic situation affected by many internal
and external forces. This situation is frequently made more
difficult by decreasing levels of government funding, in real
terms, at a time of increasing demands for education.
The school head in Africa is, therefore, in a difficult position,
being expected to deliver 'better quality' education in a
period of diminishing resources. In spite of the complexity
of problems surrounding the majority of school heads, very
few countries have seriously addressed issues relating to
their appointment, training and support. Most countries continue
to appoint heads from within the ranks of senior classroom
teachers with little or no preparation for the onerous and
complex task of school headship. It is indeed amazing that
school heads in Africa have achieved any success at all given
this background. Handy, in Dadey and Harber (1991, page 2)
describes this situation well when he says:
Given all the difficulties that schools have to cope with
as organisations, I find it truly inspiring that so much good
is achieved by so many of them. I also find it encouraging
that so many teachers still aspire to be head of such a complicated
and difficult organisation as a school.
The need for training and support for heads is probably far
stronger in Africa than in more developed and better resourced
education systems as the cost to the system of school management
by trial and error can be considerable.
This unit attempts to help you reflect on the realities of
the situation in your country and on current levels of training
provision for heads in the light of their increasingly complex
role. It is also designed to raise your awareness of the need
for self-development and life-long learning if you are to
be an effective head. It is hoped that you will extend this
awareness to your staff so that your school, as an institution,
becomes committed to self-development as it strives to achieve
the expected levels of performance.
Learning outcomes
By the end of this unit you should be able to:
explain the job description of a school head
distinguish between recruitment and selection
identify the various groups to whom the head is accountable
identify and prioritise your own personal training
needs.
The nature of school headship in Africa
A school head, to put it simply, is a person who is appointed
by the legitimate authority to manage a school. The authority
responsible for appointing school heads differs from country
to country and even within the same country, the authority
may differ depending on the kind of school. The responsibility
for appointments may lie with a Teaching Service Commission,
the Public Service Commission, the Ministry of Education or
School Boards.
Whether you were appointed by a Teaching Service Commission,
the Ministry of Education or a School Board, on appointment
you entered into a contract, written or unwritten, with your
employers. The contract binds you to be responsible and accountable
for the proper management of the school.
In some countries all promoted staff sign a contract and undergo
a probationary period. Even after completing the probationary
period there may be mechanisms to downgrade promoted staff
if they fail to meet expected levels of performance.
Given the practice in most African countries, where heads
are appointed from the ranks of classroom teachers, it is
possible that you did not receive any preparation on appointment
to headship and had to learn on-the-job by trial and error
and intuition. You probably experienced much hardship in the
process and still have a lot to learn in terms of the attitudes,
knowledge and skills needed for effective school management.
Your situation is similar to that faced by thousands of other
school heads across Africa. You are, therefore, not alone
in your attempts to improve your managerial skills.
Problems faced by heads
Heads in Africa operate in diverse economic, political, social,
cultural and geographical settings. These environments present
unique demands and challenges. Thus, the circumstances in
which you find yourself operating present both opportunities
and constraints in the realisation of projected plans. However,
an awareness of limitations and possibilities informed by
careful examination of your context of operation is more empowering
than it is discouraging. The activity that follows asks you
to study your present work context carefully with a view to
establishing your constraints and opportunities.
Activity 1.1
What factors would you say are constraints in the performance
of your duties?
What can you do to change the situation?
Comments
The constraints for many heads may include:
the scarcity or poor quality of resources (time, money,
space, facilities, staff)
the awkward size and location of the school
unqualified and underqualified teachers
a lack of continuity resulting from a high turnover
of staff
an absence of strategic planning at school, district,
regional and national levels
poor career planning for heads
large classes
lack of support for articulated policies (local or
national)
poor communication between:
-head and community
-head and ministry
-head and some sections of the school
difficult conditions of service
the slow pace of change in the system
diverse norms and values (cultural, managerial).
The above list is by no means exhaustive. However, it is
important to remember that some constraints may only be temporary
setbacks provided you try to:
be positive in your outlook (remember negative thinking
is destructive)
be creative and innovative
pick the brains of peers
be realistic about what you and your school can achieve
adopt continuous improvement as a philosophy
take full advantage of your opportunities
accept that you are not in competition with your staff,
community, other schools or the education authority (education
is a co-operative enterprise).
The above hints should assist you in coping with some of your
problems.
Activities of heads
You are probably familiar with the old adage that 'experience
is life's best teacher'. Whatever the lessons and advice that
induction to your job as a school head may have come with,
the everyday reality must bring many experiences and tasks
that are not expected.
Activity 1.2
(1) Draw up a list of your typical activities in a school
week, as a head. (2) Comment briefly on each, indicating those
that you are able to plan and schedule and those that are
more irregular and occur out of schedule.
(3) What is the proportion of scheduled to unscheduled activities,
in your circumstances?
Comments
Your list of activities might include:
visiting teachers' classes
attending to parents
procuring supplies
holding assembly
meeting heads of departments.
Depending on your individual circumstances, the proportion
of unscheduled activities may be relatively high.
If you wish to see a pattern of daily events in your school,
that satisfies you, your staff and your clients, you need
to have not only a clearly perceived and defined job description
but also a working environment in the school that enables
you and your staff to apply your energies where and when they
are most beneficial to all.
Module 1, Unit 4
mentions some ways of achieving this situation. For example,
the unit breaks down the list of activities in the head's
job description into four broad areas and considers the desirable
balance between these. One such area of the head's functions
is 'dealing with pupils, teachers and parents'.
Teachers also have their share of the normal and the abnormal
in the teaching day. If you are to build an effective team
to share the many and varied tasks in the school, you will
need to demonstrate an understanding and appreciation of the
teacher's working situation, as well as a perception of the
teacher' s view of you as head.
Activity 1.3
Ask teachers on your staff to draw up a list of the functions
and tasks they think the head should perform in the normal
course of duty and analyse the returns in order to spot any
mismatches.
Comments
The range of activities and tasks that teachers describe will
in many ways resemble those that you described earlier yourself.
The teachers may want you to:
visit classrooms and advise them
ensure maintenance of rooms and teachers' houses
call more frequent meetings
consult them on all school matters.
if you wish to build an effective team to run the school,
you should analyse these returns carefully and attempt to
identify real or perceived mismatches between what you actually
do as a head, and what the staff feels you should do. A demonstration
of corrective action by you, taken in response to their opinions,
will go a long way towards achieving a working situation in
the school that reveals high levels of staff morale and motivation.
Personnel responsibilities
Recruitment, selection, appointment and induction of staff
From experience of your education system, you probably agree
that one indicator of quality in education is the calibre
of staff appointed to positions of responsibility in the system.
Accordingly, the process of hiring personnel must be designed
to sift the best candidates from the pool, as vigorous and
reliable staff selection procedures contribute to the quality
assurance process. Module
3, Unit 1 refers to the stages in the staff selection
process.
Let us now look at the appointment of staff within the school:
Activity 1.4
Describe the process of appointment of promoted or newly appointed
staff in primary or secondary schools in your system.
Comments
You may have mentioned some of the following:
vacancy circular
advertisements of posts in the public media
seniority short-lists
interviews
letters of appointment.
The items above relate to the procedures of recruitment,
selection and appointment. The following section is designed
to supplement Module
3, Unit 1.
Recruitment
Recruitment is the process of securing internal and external
applications from which can be drawn the additional employees
that your school system may need. Such applications may be
in response to internal vacancy circulars or vacancy advertisements
in the public media. Internal applicants may be staff already
working in the system within which you work. Applicants from
other countries or alternative educational systems in the
same country would be regarded as external applicants.
Selection
Selection is the act of making a decision on the suitability
of one or more applicants from a pool.
Part of the selection process might involve:
discarding applications that do not meet the requirements
short-listing applicants according to seniority / experience
interviewing short-listed candidates at various levels
of the system.
The decision might be made on the basis of:
suitable qualifications
previous employment record and accompanying recommendations
potential of the candidate for success in the new job
performance in a selection interview.
Appointment
This refers to the formal notice assigning a successful applicant
to a specific post in a given location; for example, when
you were appointed head, you were assigned to a specific school
and post out of possibly several posts for which you might
have applied.
Induction
Induction refers to the process by which a new appointee is
assisted in understanding his new assignment on assumption
of duty. Induction can be formal or informal depending upon
existing arrangements and procedures in your system. Formal
induction is a systematic programme organised for new personnel
in a system. The programme is characterised by:
clear objectives
a schedule of activities
an evaluation of the programme
follow-up activities.
Activity 1.5
Detail the type of activities which might be included in a
formal one day induction programme for either newly-promoted
staff or for newly-qualified teachers appointed to your school.
Comments
Activities provided in a formal induction process might be:
an individual or group briefing on or off the school
site -might cover matters of school policy or the expectations
of the Ministry of Education or any other responsible authority
a comprehensive workshop organised by ministry officers
at school, district, province, or national level- might provide
an overview of departmental or other managerial responsibilities
as well as survival skills for newly-appointed staff.
Informal induction, on the other hand, is less structured.
Activity 1.6
Outline an informal introduction to your school for newly-qualified
or appointed staff.
Which members of staff might be delegated responsibility for
some of these activities?
Comments
Activities included in an informal induction might be:
a hand-over/take-over discussion with a predecessor
a guided tour of the school by an assigned member of
the school staff e.g.
the deputy head or a year / subject head
self-directed induction through reading relevant documents
and the current file of correspondence to and from the school
discussions with critical personnel in the school or
those closely associated with it (the caretaker or senior
groundsman, school suppliers).
In short, without some form of induction, staff are likely
to take a little longer to settle down thereby undermining
efficiency, effectiveness and productivity in the new job.
A common criticism of heads in Africa is that they get so
involved in trivial administrative issues that they are left
with little time, energy or inclination for the real management
issues. A further criticism is that because of inadequate
training and support, school heads tend to lack confidence
and trust, especially in their promoted staff. They feel threatened
and may be reluctant to delegate authority. Consequently,
there is very little in-house preparation for continuity of
management and when the head is away, there may be 'no one
in control'.
One of the important management skills you need to acquire
is delegation. This concept is discussed fully in Module
2, Unit 5.
Activity 1. 7
(1) What is delegation?
(2) Explain why it is necessary for you as a school manager
to delegate some of your responsibilities.
Comments
Delegation could be defined as a process by which a manager
transfers some of his responsibilities to his subordinates.
It is essential to note that when you ask a subordinate to
perform a duty on your behalf, you need to give him the necessary
authority and power to enable him to perform the task.
For Question 2, you will find some useful ideas in Module
2, Unit 5. It is also important for you to remember that
part of the reason for delegating your responsibilities is
to give yourself time to concentrate on the key management
functions of:
planning
organising
directing
supervising
evaluating
preparing your promoted staff for management roles.
It is hoped that your current efforts at self-development
win help to improve the image of school headship in Africa.
Accountability
Who are heads accountable to and how?
Education is a service provided to meet specific national
goals.
Notwithstanding the inadequacy of resources in schools, governments
spend a large proportion of their annual budget running this
service. In addition to government resources, other sources
con tribute to the system's needs.
Activity 1.8
Your school has probably received funding in cash and kind
from a number of sources during the last twelve months and
consequently these sources have a direct interest in your
school.
(1) List these sources.
(2) What does each source expect out of your school?
(3) List other sources which have a direct interest in your
school.
Comments
You will probably have included the following in your answer:
the government
the local community
the local authority or other responsible authority,
such as a church organisation or a private trust
parents and pupils.
In subsequent paragraphs, we will look at the various groups
that may have a direct interest in your school, to whom you
may be accountable. These groups have a bearing on the skills
and knowledge you may need to acquire in order to improve
your effectiveness as a school head.
In most countries, the provision of education is the collective
responsibility of a variety of agencies and institutions.
While governments, to a large extent, bear the bulk of educational
costs through payment of salaries, grants and subsidies, local
communities in Africa are generally responsible for infrastructural
costs.
Each of the sources you listed in Activity 1.8 will expect
certain outputs and outcomes from your school and will hold
you accountable for these.
The government
Schools are generally accountable to the government for their
effectiveness through their ministries. Module
6, Unit 3 describes how this is done through the various
sections of the Ministries of Education.
You, as head, have to account for:
the professional competence of your staff
the management of the curriculum
the management and use of all resources
the quality of graduates from your school.
You need to be clear about ministry expectations and the reporting
structures to be followed.
The local authority or other responsible group
The provision of physical structures may be the responsibility
of a local authority, such as a city council or it may be
some other authority, such as a church group or private trust.
In this respect you, as head, will find yourself accountable
to this authority for, among other things:
the maintenance of the school plant
the management of resources
developing or maintaining a school ethos consistent
with the mission of the responsible authority.
You need to clarify with your authority the 'accounting'
procedures to be followed. You may be required to submit reports
or returns at regular intervals or carry out an audit of some
kind.
The local community
While you are accountable formally to and have a contract
with the two groups first discussed, the local community is
a very powerful group to which you are also accountable even
though you may have no formal contract with it. The local
community usually contributes a great deal in cash and kind
to the development of the school and you draw your clients
from it. The school, in this sense, is part of the community.
You as head are, therefore, accountable to it for:
imparting skills, knowledge and attitudes that are
relevant to its needs
bringing about desired change while maintaining the
desirable values and norms
rendering some form of 'community service'.
You will need to establish formal and informal links with
the community so that you become aware of and anticipate its
needs. You have probably noted that the majority of schools
serve rural communities and these communities are fairly solid
and homogeneous with clear authority structures. The influence
of these authority structures extends into the school. You
will benefit from acknowledging the local community leadership
and communicating regularly with it. You may have noticed
that all that is required is to keep the leadership informed
of developments and not necessarily seek their permission.
Overlooking local leadership could lead to tension which can
hinder school development.
The parents
The parents of your pupils are a special group of the local
community to whom you are particularly accountable. Because
of the simplicity of most of the rural folks who form the
bulk of the parents, school heads do not always regard this
group with the seriousness it deserves. You need to appreciate
that you are accountable to individual parents for the achievements
of their children and in ensuring that they get value for
money in terms of learning gains for their children.
The pupils
Your school and you, as head, would not exist if there were
no pupils.
Pupils are all too often taken for granted and few heads see
themselves as being accountable to pupils. You owe it to your
pupils to ensure that:
a healthy school tone and discipline prevail in your
school
opportunities for guidance and counselling are afforded
to every child
pupils are kept informed of what is expected of them
and what is happening in the school.
It is not often that pupils will demand that you account
to them for these and other issues but if you are consistently
insensitive to their expectations you could be sitting on
a time bomb which could find expression in strikes and destruction
of property.
We hope that you now appreciate the complexity of your job
as a head if only from the point of view of having to handle
a wide range of interest groups and accounting to these groups
for the effectiveness of your school.
Training for heads
The need for training for school heads has remained strong
in Africa through the years. The complexity of schools as
organisations and the demands of the job have been clearly
described in the foregoing paragraphs and are acknowledged
by all in the field of education. Recognition of this fact
is partly responsible for the training trends that have emerged
in many countries. Let us examine these briefly.
Activity 1.9
(1) How many training courses have you attended in the last
three years?
(2) How were these organised and what was the content of the
courses?
Comments
Did the course(s):
arise from consultation with local heads?
address matters to improve your performance as head?
arise from some general ministry plan?
An honest assessment will help you to consider the next set
of ideas.
What is training?
Case study
Two circuits in the same district were fortunate to find themselves
scheduled for training activities. Both heads received two
invitations, one from their education office to attend a three-day
workshop at the district training centre on the theme 'School
Development Planning' and the other from the National Heads
Association (NHA) to gather at the same venue a fortnight
later. The Association invitation stating plainly that the
purpose of the meeting was to: 'exchange and share experiences
in the area of staff motivation and morale'.
When the two heads met and one asked the other if he was
also going to attend both meetings, his counterpart replied,
'Oh no, I am going to attend the three-day workshop at the
district training centre. I do not think it will be necessary
for me to go to the NHA meeting as well'.
How might we explain the different attitude of the two heads?
In our part of the world the formal training course, seminar
or workshop is often a rare and precious commodity because
funds just do not permit a systematic and regular cycle of
programmes. The result is that the formal training course
has tended to become highly sought after and has acquired
a halo of prestige. The more informal alternative -meetings
of heads, an ex change of visits or consultation with peers
in a neighbourhood -is viewed by some heads themselves as
of less importance.
However, such meetings are:
simple to organise
do not cost much
deal mainly with everyday matters.
Heads should consider the implications of such meetings for
their professional growth and performance very seriously.
Research in the region has shown that national coverage, in
terms of formal training for heads, ranges from as little
as 2 percent to no more than 10 percent in most countries.
With the sheer growth in numbers, this proportion is not
likely to improve. In view of current economic trends on the
continent, few countries will be able to improve let alone
institutionalise in-service training budgets. It is almost
a certainty that formal training, as it is commonly perceived,
will remain sporadic and inconsistent.
Activity 1.10
We said in the earlier case study that 'training' implies
a formal affair that is external to the individual head.
How would you define the other type of forum whereby heads
get together and initiate their own learning experiences?
Comments
Your ideas may include expressions such as:
staff development
professional development
on-the-job training
self-development.
Whatever the term used, heads need to consider carefully
the benefits of these alternative approaches to 'training'.
The Headteacher Training and Support Programme for Africa
is one example of such an alternative approach. You will see
in Unit 2 of this module a full
account of the programme. Let us consider its benefits:
It provides the head with a set of hands-on materials.
It taps the available resources in the district, the
region or province both in terms of materials, facilities
and funds as well as expertise.
The programme is viable and sustainable and cannot
disappear overnight {unless heads allow it to).
It is flexible in terms of delivery and is determined
by the head or group of heads.
It is situation specific.
It ad dresses both individual and group needs.
As a head you will need to consider whether the occasional
funded gathering or the local or school-focused staff development
or self-development programme is likely to see you develop
and grow in your career.
One solution to the problem is to identify clearly the training
needs of heads and the system as a whole from the outset.
Nations, their institutions and the personnel manning those
institutions are linked in an interactive relationship. As
nations develop and grow so will their institutions and personnel,
giving rise to a variety of training needs.
Module 1, Unit 3,
pages 15-24 will assist you in identifying the needs of various
stakeholders in the educational enterprise. In order to ensure
the survival, efficiency and effectiveness of the educational
enterprise, training should play an important part in addressing
and harmonising the needs of key personnel like yourself with
the needs of your institution and with national needs as determined
by policy-makers. In this context personal needs are to be
consistent with institutional needs. In order to understand
training needs properly at the personal, institutional and
national levels, you should examine the factors that dictate
these needs.
Activity 1.11
List the factors that give rise to training needs at the three
levels identified above.
Comments
In your list of factors, you probably identified some of the
following:
the desire to be a more competent head
the variety of experiences heads bring to their schools
on appointment
the different levels of maturity in heads
a desire to keep abreast of the knowledge explosion
changing educational trends
social changes reflected in the enactment of new laws
(affirmative action legislation, for example)
new directions charted by new governments taking office
changes in societal, professional, managerial attitudes
changes in relationships of accountability; for example,
is the head in Africa more or less accountable to parents
and pupils today than ten years ago?
In addition to the above factors, you will have noticed from
reading earlier parts of this unit that training needs could
be determined by:
the nature of your job and the responsibilities it
entails
the selection and induction process
accountability relationships and expectations arising
therefrom
operational problems.
The paragraphs above provide some indication of the factors
that underscore training needs. However, it is important for
you to understand your specific training needs in areas accepted
as constituting the core of your managerial activities (refer
to Module 6, Unit 1,
page 9).
To this end, part of a needs assessment instrument is provided
for you overleaf. You will see in the instrument that:
a critical behaviour is identified, in this case leadership
the behaviour is broken down into components, ten for
leadership
a rating key is provided (low /moderate/high).
Activity 1.12
(1) Complete the needs assessment instrument for leadership
behaviour on pages 18-19 indicating:
-the significance you attach to a component with regard to your
role as a head (importance to this position)
-your current performance in that component (level of proficiency)
-the strength of need for growth in that component (need for
growth)
(2) Rate the following leadership proficiencies in the same
manner (Appendix A, page 67):
communication skills |
group processes |
curriculum management |
instruction |
performance |
evaluation |
organisational management |
financial management |
political management |
|
Note: The full set of critical behaviours is attached
in Appendix A as adapted from Proficiencies for Principals,
National Association of Elementary School Principals.
Comments
The needs assessment has enabled you to:
determine where you are now in your mastery of desirable
knowledge, skills, and attitudes in the management of your
school
establish the extent and urgency of your needs as they
relate to yourself, your school, your district, your region
and country
state your training needs.
Prioritising training needs
Module 1, Unit 3
and the foregoing sections of the current module have shown
you that you will probably be confronted by a variety of training
needs. In practice it is not possible for you to address all
your needs at once.
Instead you should deal with some clearly identified needs
in a methodical manner.
Activity 1.13
Using the needs assessment instrument you completed in the
section above, write down your needs in some form of priority
order.
What were your ranking criteria?
Comments
Some of the following considerations might have helped you
to rank your needs:
personal preferences
strength of current needs
relevance of needs
public pressures
pressure from the employer, education authorities or
other interested groups
inherent interest in learning or acquiring new skills,
attitudes or knowledge.
To rank your needs is to place them in priority order. Fig
1 shows a chart you might use to rank your management tasks.
You could also ask your staff to prioritise them. Compare
the final results and identify specific needs relating to
each prioritised task.
Activity 1.14
Fig 1 lists 12 key management tasks most of which you normally
perform as head.
Using a scale of 1 (not important) to 5 (very important),
prioritise these tasks. Ask your staff to do the same and
compare the results.
Comments
The activity just completed will probably have given you the
opportunity to see how much common ground exists between you
and your staff with regard to priority tasks. In addition,
you will have been able to determine whether your needs in
those task areas have been met. While an instrument like the
one you used offers a method of prioritising tasks and needs,
it is important to remember that the prioritising of needs
cannot be divorced from your school's operational context.
You must seek to establish harmony between your needs, those
of your school, the expectations of public offices and other
interested groups.
Summary
In this unit we touched on the complexity and demands of the
role of the head in Africa. We discussed the variety of challenges
and problems you face. To ensure that you are equal to the
job demands, you were presented with modes of training available
to you. Without the training that answers your needs, you
are ill prepared to meet the expectations of the various groups. |